Wordless(ish) Wednesday: Shoe Advice

We are headed to a wedding this weekend and I couldn't be more excited. I have a fun red dress picked out, but now I need help with my shoes. Assuming the weather is cool enough I'm planning on wearing black tights. But which shoes?? Which of these three would you wear?

probably my favorite, but is sandals with tights a thing?

Some oldies, but goodies

Plain jane (obvi), but suuuuuper comfy.

Advice, please!